← Back
Gone: Deluxe Hardcover Vol. 1 cover

DSTLRY / Gone

Gone: Deluxe Hardcover Vol. 1

Volume 1

Reading statusRead
My rating8/10

Purchase details

Purchased fromHumble Bundle

BundleDSTLRY Bundle

Bundle price£17.00

Average cost per volume£0.43

My review

Premise grabbed me immediately. I loved the suggestion of the world. I loved the hard science of time moving more slowly for people back on the planet, relative to those moving at relativistic speeds on the ship. Artwork and style were excellent. The mystery of the pink cloud was really cool. The ending felt quite rushed though. It became a series of things that happened. The main character was just trying to get home the whole time and they effectively got a rescue from friendlies who immediately agreed to take her back. A bit of a weak ending, but overall very nice! Very inspiring too, made me want to do something with a nice small scope. Pretty fun one. I'd have liked a hard choice at the end though. She stranded herself in the first place in order to ensure the others got out alive. That was a heroic sacrifice. Would she make the same call after over a decade hiding on that ship? Maybe she finds a way home at the expense of someone else. That would be interesting. I think making the right choice and seeing the pain she goes through while maintaining her moral/ethical code could be powerful. I think her making a selfish choice is more unique and potentially more interesting, but it's hard to get an emotional pay off. So she abandons someone to death or solitude in order to get home, then what? I could go really dark and have it so the family have moved on, or died, or reject her in some way making it all for nothing. Or she gets home and finds that home has changed, she has changed and she no longer has the home in that location. Pretty grim though. Maybe she justifies the betrayal to herself in a kind of cognitive dissonance. I'm more drawn to the idea that she does not make the heroic sacrifice again, but it is hard to come up with an emotional payoff. There has to be a consequence. Maybe the reunion with family is everything she wanted and appears joyous, but she looks in the mirror and sees the face of those she deserted and it haunts here, colouring her joyous time with guilt?