
These Savage Shores: The Definitive Edition
Volume 1
Purchase details
Purchased fromHumble Bundle
BundleVault Bundle
Bundle price£13.48
Average cost per volume£0.39
My review
Artwork was wonderful, the setting was exciting and really interesting to me, I like the time of the English occupation in India and the beauty and history of India itself. The fantastical elements were excellent. I really enjoyed the unique creature (it may be something existing in Indian folklore, but it was new to me and it felt fresh and exciting). The emotional payoff was lacking in the end. It set up this sweeping narrative with the English advance and the plots between established Indian nobility. Ultimately, there was a big fight with a Dracula being and it ended there. When his lover said I hold you to your word to take him down at any cost and she offered him her blood, I thought he was going to have to kill her in order to kill the vampire, but after the battle, it cuts to India and she's alive and well. I think it did a lot right, and I really enjoyed reading it. I just think it was a bit let down in the end. I like to try to think how I'd improve a story rather than just saying it wasn't up to par. I think having his choice to seriously risk his lovers' life in order to defeat the vampire would have been better. Maybe even have him choose his lover and forego revenge. There was a panel before the fight where he said in his long years he's forgotten cities that have sunk into the sea etc, but that he always remembers the choices. I think for him to choose to forego revenge and even be taunted by the vampire would have been interesting, or keep the revenge but refuse his lovers blood and lose the fight. Go down swinging. I don't know, but something more emotionally impactful would have been interesting. Also his lover said her sire (the vampire) is always in the back of her mind and that they are bound. I'd like to have seen some consequence of that. Maybe as the vampire is injured, she cries out in pain. Or once he's dead she feels great relief. Something to drive that home and explore the bond a bit. Cool story anyway. My first one from the Vault bundle.